CommandEleven Intelligence Desk // South Asia Desk, status as of Thursday, November 19, 2026. This is an update to the Pakistan-Afghanistan series.
Bottom Line Up Front
Pakistan is pressing Kabul on four fronts at once: air strikes, a near-total trade cutoff, diplomacy at the UN and in Washington, and, by one report, quiet contact with Afghan anti-Taliban groups. None of these has moved the Taliban. Pakistani police are still being killed in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, and border posts are still trading fire.
The public record supports the shape of this pressure but not every number attached to it. The most repeated figure, that bilateral trade fell 95%, is not supported by the Pakistani data we could find. Pakistani figures reported by Dawn show a fall of about 74%, from roughly $1.3 billion to $358 million, in fiscal 2025-26. Transit trade fell further, by about 87% in containers and 93% in value against pre-2021 levels. The collapse is real and severe. The headline number is wrong.
Two other claims in circulation also need correction. The “4,700 Pakistanis killed” figure is Pakistan’s own claim, made at the UN Security Council in mid-September by Ambassador Asim Iftikhar Ahmad. It is not an independent count. And Secretary of State Marco Rubio on October 31 offered only a conditional role: “if there’s a productive role for us to play, we’ll play it.”
Key Judgments
- CONFIRMED (high confidence): On September 18, an attack on the Old Police Lines complex in Kohat killed at least 31 people, including 16 police, and injured more than 100. Ittehad-ul-Mujahideen Pakistan, a TTP-linked group, claimed it. Source: AFP via Gulf News.
- CONFIRMED (high confidence): Pakistani strikes on the night of September 30 to October 1 in Kunar and Helmand killed at least 10 civilians, most of them children, and injured nine, according to the UN mission in Afghanistan. Pakistan says it killed 22 militants. That claim is unverified. Source: AP via CP24.
- CONFIRMED (high confidence): Bilateral trade fell about 74% in fiscal 2025-26, to $358 million from about $1.3 billion, per official Pakistani figures reported by Dawn. The 95% figure that appears in some summaries is not supported by those figures.
- CONFIRMED (high confidence): Transit cargo through Pakistan fell to 11,592 containers worth about $367 million in fiscal 2026, from nearly 89,000 containers and about $5 billion before the Taliban returned in 2021. Reverse transit fell from $454 million to $7 million. Source: Dawn, via the Afghan Studies Center.
- CONFIRMED (high confidence): The 4,700 figure is a Pakistani government claim. Ambassador Asim Iftikhar Ahmad told the Security Council that more than 4,700 Pakistanis had been killed over three years in terrorism “emanating from Afghanistan.” Source: Dawn, Arab News Pakistan.
- CONFIRMED (high confidence): Rubio’s October 31 offer was conditional and undefined. Source: Express Tribune.
- REPORTED, NOT CONFIRMED (moderate confidence that talks occurred): The New York Times reported on October 22 that Pakistani military and intelligence officials have met Afghan anti-Taliban resistance groups in recent months. The sources were a Pakistani intelligence official and a senior resistance member. The groups are not named. Pakistan has denied arming or recruiting Afghans to fight the Taliban. Source: Long War Journal.
- ASSESSED (moderate confidence): The pressure is escalating without producing Taliban concessions. The evidence is continuing attacks and border fire, not any Taliban statement of intent.

What Is Confirmed
The attacks. After Kohat, a TTP ambush on November 11 in the Gumbat area of Kohat district killed 10 police officers and wounded 12, and Pakistani sources say 18 fighters were killed. The Pakistani Taliban claimed it. The officers were returning from an operation against illegal gold mining. Source: Al Jazeera. Pakistani authorities cite 1,327 deaths and 2,484 injuries in 2026 from terrorism they attribute to Afghanistan. That is an official claim, not an independent count.
The strikes and civilian toll. The UN mission said in late September that it had documented more than 1,100 civilian deaths and injuries from cross-border violence in 2026. Pakistan says its strikes are “well planned and calibrated” and that its campaign “will continue at full pace.”
The border. Clashes have continued. On October 19, Taliban and Pakistani forces exchanged heavy weapons fire for several hours along the Paktika border. On October 27, fighting was reported between Paktika and Lower South Waziristan, and Pakistani authorities reported one civilian killed and five wounded by a mortar. On October 28, fighting was reported at Torkham. On November 5, security sources told Radio Pakistan that Afghan Taliban forces fired first at the Shalozan sector of Kurram and that Afghan posts were heavily damaged. Taliban and Pakistani accounts of who fired first conflict. Sources: Long War Journal, Radio Pakistan.
The border economy. Border crossings have been mostly closed for more than a year. A leader of the Pakistan-Afghanistan Joint Chamber of Commerce told reporters, “We no longer have trade with Pakistan.”

Corrections to Figures in Circulation
- Trade fell 95% in fiscal 2026. Pakistani data via Dawn: about 74%, from roughly $1.3 billion to $358 million. The 95% figure appears in some digests and in a Long War Journal passage, but we could not trace it to the Pakistani figures.
- 4,700 Pakistanis killed, stated at the UN on October 29 by “Javad Ajmal.” Stated by Ambassador Asim Iftikhar Ahmad in mid-September, not October 29. It is Pakistan’s claim.
- Rubio “reaffirmed readiness to play a constructive role in resolving the conflict.” He said “if there’s a productive role for us to play, we’ll play it,” and defined no role.
- Clashes since “late October.” Armed conflict dates to October 2025. Fighting this autumn follows the September 18 Kohat attack.
- November 5: Pakistan thwarted a TTP infiltration. Radio Pakistan’s report, citing security sources, describes Afghan Taliban forces firing first in Kurram. Its headline refers to an infiltration attempt.
The trade discrepancy matters most. A reader who sees 95% will treat the border as sealed. The Pakistani data shows a collapse that is severe but not total, and that leaves room for Afghan trade to reroute. Dawn data cited by the Friday Times shows Pakistan’s exports to Afghanistan fell about 69% to $243.7 million in fiscal 2026. Afghan trade did not stop: Reuters data cited in the same analysis puts Afghanistan’s total trade at about $13.9 billion in 2025, and the World Bank counts Iran as the largest source of its imports.
The Pressure Ladder
- Force. Air strikes continue despite UN-documented civilian deaths.
- Economics. The trade cutoff has cost Pakistan too. Pakistan’s own exports to Afghanistan fell by more than two thirds, and transit income has collapsed.
- Diplomacy. At the UN, Pakistan told the Council it would “respond in self-defence, as and when needed.” In Atlanta, Rubio said the US is “against terrorism no matter where it emanates from.”
- Proxies. The reported contact with resistance groups would be a new rung. It rests on one newspaper’s anonymous sources. If true, it widens the conflict beyond the TTP issue. If false or exaggerated, it still signals to Kabul.
What Is Not Established
- That Pakistan is arming, funding or directing any Afghan resistance group. Pakistan denies it, and the New York Times report names no group.
- The Pakistani claim that 22 militants died on October 1.
- Pakistan’s claim of more than 4,700 dead. The figure rests on Pakistani data we could not independently verify.
- Current trade figures. No official data covering the period since Governor’s Rule was imposed in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa on October 11 has been published, so the 74% figure describes fiscal 2025-26 only.
- The share of TTP fighters who are Afghan. Pakistani security officials estimate up to 70% of infiltrating militants are of Afghan origin. That is an official estimate.
What To Watch
- The reported Kandahar deadline. Our November 1 assessment recorded a reported October 22 Kandahar session that set a 30-day deadline near November 21. It rests on one source. Watch whether anything changes at the border or in Islamabad’s rhetoric this weekend.
- Torkham. Whether any commercial traffic reopens.
- UNAMA’s next civilian casualty update and any new Pakistani strike inside Afghanistan.
- Resistance groups. Whether any named group confirms or denies contact with Pakistani officials.
- Washington. Whether Rubio’s conditional offer becomes an envoy, a mediation track or a statement of terms.
- Kohat and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Whether attacks on police continue at the November 11 scale.
Calls We Will Score
- By Thursday, December 31, 2026, Torkham remains closed to regular commercial transit trade.
- By Thursday, December 31, 2026, at least one new Pakistani strike inside Afghanistan is reported by UNAMA or a major wire service.
- By Sunday, January 31, 2027, a named Afghan anti-Taliban resistance group publicly confirms a meeting with Pakistani officials.
- By Sunday, January 31, 2027, the US government publicly names a specific mediation role, envoy or process for the Pakistan-Afghanistan dispute.
What This Assessment Does and Doesn’t Establish
It establishes what primary reporting, wire services and Pakistani official data show about the attacks, strikes, border fighting and trade, and it corrects specific figures that circulated in summaries. It does not establish who is winning, whether the Taliban will act against the TTP, or whether Pakistan is supporting Afghan resistance groups. Pakistani official claims are labeled as claims. We relied on public sources. Where those conflict, as on who fired first at the border, we give both accounts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did Pakistan-Afghanistan trade fall 95%?
Not by the Pakistani data we found. Official figures reported by Dawn show bilateral trade falling about 74%, to $358 million in fiscal 2025-26. Transit trade fell about 87% in containers and 93% in value against pre-2021 levels.
Who gave the 4,700 deaths figure?
Pakistan’s Ambassador to the UN, Asim Iftikhar Ahmad, told the Security Council in mid-September that more than 4,700 Pakistanis had been killed over three years by terrorism he attributed to Afghanistan. It is a Pakistani government claim.
What did the UN say about the October 1 strikes?
The UN mission in Afghanistan said at least 10 civilians, most of them children, were killed and nine injured in Kunar and Helmand. Pakistan says it hit militants and killed 22. That claim is unverified.
Is Pakistan backing Afghan resistance groups?
The New York Times reported meetings between Pakistani officials and resistance groups, citing a Pakistani intelligence official and a resistance member. Pakistan denies arming or recruiting Afghans. The groups are not named.
Has the US taken a side?
Rubio said Washington is “against terrorism no matter where it emanates from” and would play a “productive role” if one exists. He did not define a role.
Related CommandEleven Intelligence Reading
- A Region Under Pressure: The Pakistan-Afghanistan Series
- Open War: The 2026 Pakistan-Afghanistan Escalation Timeline – Part 1
- The TTP Sanctuary Question: Mapping a Denied Safe Haven – Part 2
- Hamza bin Laden and Al-Qaeda’s Regional Re-Emergence – Part 3
- The Baloch Insurgency Uptick: A Second Front Under Pressure – Part 4
- Synthesis: A Region Under Simultaneous Pressure – Part 5
- The Front Moves South: Angoor Adda, Torkham and the October Border War – Part 6
- Pakistan and the Taliban After Kandahar: A Year of Failed Mediation and a Deadline Near November 21
Sources
- AFP via Gulf News, Pakistan police complex attack kills 31, Sep 18-19, 2026
- AP via CP24, Pakistani airstrikes in Afghanistan kill 10 civilians, Oct 1, 2026
- Dawn, Pakistan tells UNSC it will respond in self-defence, Sep 17, 2026
- Arab News Pakistan, UN envoy says Afghanistan-based militants killed over 4,700 Pakistanis, Sep 2026
- Express Tribune, Rubio says US open to role on Pakistan’s Afghan terror concerns, Nov 1, 2026
- Al Jazeera, Ten police officers, 18 fighters killed in northwest Pakistan attack, Nov 12, 2026
- Radio Pakistan, Security forces foil infiltration attempt in Kurram, Nov 5, 2026
- Long War Journal, Afghanistan-Pakistan border clashes continue amid reported Pakistani outreach, Oct 29, 2026
- Long War Journal, Pakistani outreach presents a dilemma for Afghanistan’s anti-Taliban resistance, Oct 26, 2026
- Afghan Studies Center (Dawn), transit trade falls to $367 million in FY26, Jul 20, 2026
- Friday Times, Pakistan Is Losing Afghanistan’s Trade and Its Gateway to Central Asia, Nov 12, 2026
- UNI, Af-Pak trade sees drastic decline, Oct 19, 2026

