Russia Today · Broadcast November 30, 2022
Summary
Syed Khalid Muhammad on RT International after the TTP ended its ceasefire, and Pakistan's options against a group sheltering in Afghanistan.
Transcript
This transcript was generated from the broadcast and lightly edited. Sponsor messages and music are removed, speaker names are corrected, and some remarks by panelists and guests that do not reflect the views of CommandEleven Intelligence have been removed. Automatic transcription may contain errors; the video is the record.
Host: Well, to discuss the deadly attacks, we cross live to independent security analyst and director general of the CommandEleven think tank, Syed Khalid Muhammad. You’re most welcome, sir. The Pakistani Taliban pulled out of a months long ceasefire days ago. And now we have this deadly bombing. Does this open a new violent chapter that Pakistan will be dealing with?
Khalid: Well, this chapter was never actually closed. The TTP has never actually accepted anything that the government of Pakistan has said, nor have they ever actually declared peace between the government of Pakistan and the TTP. If you remember, over the past two years we have had attacks in the FATA region. We have had two attacks on the Chinese consular officials in Karachi and in Quetta. They have never declared peace with Pakistan. They have continued on over and over making peace agreements and declaring ceasefires, but they have never ceased fire. Their argument today is that the government of Pakistan, the military of Pakistan continues to wage war against the TTP. Well as long as you’re against the state of Pakistan, we will fight you. So this is not a new chapter, this is a continuing book. We could call this a sequel to book one, if you like to say.
Host: What kind of a response then from the Pakistani authorities do you expect following this?
Khalid: Well, if you remember, after the army public school attack in Peshawar, the army of Pakistan went headstrong into Afghanistan. They put a lot of pressure on the Afghani government. Now we have a government in Afghanistan that is the Taliban, which many people consider to believe is a part of the Pakistani military establishment. The Taliban has assured Pakistan that their soil would not be used against any other country. Yet the TTP enjoys safe haven. They enjoy clean relations with the Taliban, and they have no interest in bringing any stop to this warfare. The only option the government of Pakistan actually has is to declare open war against the Taliban, the TTP, not the Taliban in Afghanistan, but the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan. That is what we did during the Raheel Sharif government, during the time when Raheel Sharif was our chief of army staff. There was bombings across the borderlines. We fired mortars into Afghanistan, taking out TTP camps. We sent in targeted assassins to take out top leadership. That is the only way to beat these guys. This is one thing where this is not something we can sit at the table and work out. They only understand force because they only use force. So the only answer to them is immense force.
Host: Can I expand on something you just said there, though? Taliban’s minister of state for foreign affairs met with his Afghan counterpart to discuss what occurred. Is there something, something more that the Taliban government in Afghanistan can do to control those operating in Pakistan?
Khalid: Well, here’s where the problem is. Pakistan, even though we have fenced a 3,200-kilometer border with Afghanistan, there are still patches where the Taliban can cross. There are places where they’ve cut it. We can put all kinds of pressure on the Taliban. But the biggest pressure piece we can use is cutting off the border. So we don’t supply any food. We don’t supply any building materials. That is the biggest pressure we can bring on the Taliban right now. But the government of Pakistan cannot make that decision because the international community will not let us make that decision. If we try and starve the Taliban out of Afghanistan to make them take action against a terrorist group, that is just like invading Afghanistan. So our hands are very, very handcuffed in this situation. Either we declare open war and we go after them with full strength, not being concerned about the border, or we fight them inside our country and let them keep their safe havens in Afghanistan, which is not a workable solution. So even though our minister of state may have met with the Afghani counterpart in the Taliban, We have sent Mullah Taqi Usman to Afghanistan to try and convince the Afghan Taliban to take the Pakistan position and put pressure on the TTP. But that did not work. We have now brought ministry level into the conversation. That has not worked. We are headed towards a military solution. Because even though none of us like the idea of the military being involved and taking this to a bloodshed level. Because if you wage war against the TTP, they will wage war against the people of Pakistan. From 2007 until 2009, we lost 80,000 lives. Now, we are not ready to sacrifice 80,000 people again when the Taliban sitting across the border in Afghanistan are not willing to be friends and hold up to their agreements with us.
Host: Okay. The TTP, as we mentioned, they announced the end of their ceasefire, as much as that was worth, as you’ve been going through. Can you just give us a sense of why that might have occurred, why they’re engaging now in this level of violence?
Khalid: Well, let me explain for one from the beginning. From 2003 until, sorry, from In 2007 until 2013, we did eight different ceasefire and peace agreements with the TTP. They were the first ones to break the agreement on their own, whether it was the TTP itself or whether it was the splinter group of the TTP that waged war, that continued to wage war against the military and the people of Pakistan. The problem we have today that they are claiming that the TTP is saying that one of our conditions for peace was that the FATA region that has not been merged into Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, that that be again separated and turned back into a tribal area. Now, that means that the government of Pakistan cannot bring schools, cannot bring hospitals, cannot bring electricity, cannot bring gas, cannot build roads, because you want us to keep them outside of the state of Pakistan. We want to bring the FATA region into Pakistan, where we can provide you all of the facilities that are available to every other Pakistani throughout Pakistan. The TTP’s main condition, the reason they claim that they’ve broken the ceasefire, is because we refuse to break the merger. We refuse to take FATA out of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and make it a tribal region again.
Host: And also because one of the group’s founding members was killed.
Khalid: Sir, the founding member, they are talking about Khalid Umar Khorasani. Khalid Umar Umar Khorasani was shot and was executed by a U.S. drone attack. Pakistan had nothing to do with it. To wage war against us for something that the Americans did is extremely unfair. It was not the Pakistan military that killed Umar Khaled Umar Khorasani. It was the U.S. military with a drone strike. And on that same day, if you recall, in Pakistan a helicopter was shot down in Quetta, where four generals died in that attack. And the Americans claim that we misfire, hit that helicopter, and then we hit Umar Khaled Khorasani. Now, the story that you have to understand is that the Americans took out the top leader inside the TTP. Where is it Pakistan’s fault that we should pay the price for your attack? The drone was not lost on Pakistani soil. Soldiers did not come from Pakistani soil. Why are you waging war against us?
Host: Well, thank you so much for coming on the program and sharing your expertise with us and giving us a sense of what occurred today with those people dead in Pakistan. Thank you very much. Syed Khalid Muhammad in the Pakistani capital, Islamabad.