Fault Lines · Aired December 10, 2022
Summary
How ISIS, which once held territory and recruited from more than 100 countries, is spreading into new regions, and the threat it poses to Pakistan and Afghanistan.
Transcript
This transcript was generated from the broadcast and lightly edited. Sponsor messages and music are removed, speaker names are corrected, and some remarks by panelists and guests that do not reflect the views of CommandEleven Intelligence have been removed. Automatic transcription may contain errors; the video is the record.
[00:00:02] foreign today we are going to discuss one of the most remarkable organizations militant organizations of our contemporary times Isis or daesh this organization has got many names i s i l i s i k daesh and thus goes on but collectively all of these names have a spread Terror and fear on a remarkable extent not only it remained a state back in 2014 but also became an ideal log for many people and successfully recruited terrorists from over 100 nation yes Isis was once having manpar consisting of people carrying Canadian British American and many other passports Isis that initially started from Iraq and Syria is now spreading the wealth of its venom in many other parts of the world one of which is Africa today we will see how daesh is spreading in all these parts of the world team fault lines have prepared a package watch the package before I bring my first guest to the program World faces the prospect of revived security threat from transnational terror group Islamic State the emergence of isil the umbrella organization that includes iskp has often been attributed to sectarian Dynamics but the armed
[00:01:46] group has bloody Legacy of stalking violence indiscriminately isil was formed by defectors from al-Qaeda in 2014 in Syria who then attacked their parent organization in its Syrian affiliate jab hathil anusra while iskp was formed primarily by defectors from the Taliban in both Afghanistan and Pakistan in 2015 who then went on to attack the Afghan Branch Islamic State corazon's transition into a trans Regional threat forces additional danger and evidence suggests that iskp's tentacles have begun spreading across West Central and South Asia early in 2022 iskp warned of a new era of global Jihad in the following months it not only expanded its operation across the amudharya an Uzbekistan and Tajikistan but it also targeted the Russian an embassy in gobble and then claimed responsibility of attack on Pakistan Embassy in Kabul in 2018 more than 80 percent of his Islamic States activity was concentrated in Iraq and Syria now the majority of its attacks are staged in Africa Islamic State extremists dominate vast regions of central Mali Northern Burkina Faso and Niger with
[00:02:50] attacks reaching as far as Benin and Togo in assessing the potential of Isis the need is to acknowledge that the organization is not an Insurgency seeking territorial gains but it's steadfast in its determination to proliferate its ideological strategic and tactical reach to entire world ladies and gentlemen we'll take a short break before we discuss this topic with the first guest of the program stay tuned to join me in this part of my program my first guest is Mr Ahmad Zaki he's a famous Middle Eastern expert also an expert on African Affairs and frequently appears I'm not sure welcome to the show thank you for having me we're talking about the manners of Isis or daesh or isil they have multiple names a recent name is isik all originating from One Foundation organization but I want to start this conversation from you because it has been heard that this organization is penetrating now in various parts of Africa what's your quick feedback on
[00:04:10] that as you know that central Africa Eastern Africa and even western Africa now the terrorist organization is with various different names and very different agenda they are spreading all across Africa now I can say that there is no state in Africa that has not been affected whether they are rich or poor they have different level of effect when you see that the East African countries and Central African countries they are most affected one like from Somalia Ethiopia Kenya Uganda that's one side affected by al-shabab when we come to that side of the list of the countries but generally speaking what do you believe can be the reason that uh organizations like taish are finding warm breeding grounds in the landscape of Africa generally what can be the reason for that there are two reasons number one is that the state institutions in Africa are not that capable to control all of their land that is number one and number two the corruption level of the African state is where there is no democratic transition of the government is dictators the
[00:05:18] people are already feeling that they have been overpowered by the government they without listening their demand so they have some sort of sympathy from the African people so in the beginning they they are getting support from the local people because they are against their their own our governments on the other side the buffet uh and the food shortage in African states are also participating in this this type of it's actually banking on your knowledge about the different countries of Africa would it be fine if we go through the list of the countries that are affected obviously so so the first country that comes to my mind is Nigeria now tell how Nigeria is affected whether Nigeria is the hotbed of the of the terrorist currently Boko Haram is the most and the most powerful and largest Terror organization in Africa they are they likely they are attacking the schools they're abducting 400 200 girls with all the international media and international forces are can watch it without any assistance they feel helpless
[00:06:24] the people of Nigeria but is it uh got something to do with daesh or you're generally speaking about the terrorism definitely daesh is is a new form of al-Qaeda in Africa or what we call it they have all in same category of the they are fighting in the neighbors but Boko Haram is it also related with definitely it's it's the mother of daish in Africa all right now let's talk about Somalia a country that is most affected one of the most affected countries yeah you being an expert on somalia's Affairs I think you have a background from there as well tell us how militants is affecting Somalia militant is in in Somalia they are al-shabab Al-Qaeda related the largest Al-Qaeda Affiliated branch in in in in the world it's called al-shabab and they they are operating all East Africa not only Somalia Somalia is their main Hub currently they were reduced in their activities but still you can see their influence are are exist in the capital city and some Southern and central part of Somalia and that is how
[00:07:29] al-shabab like by spreading fear and Terror they are still showing their existence by attacking them like last week attack on on the hotels they are attacking hotels they are attacking public whether in government offices sometimes they even they are attacking the air and all these attacks are melting down the capacity of the state to fight with them obviously state is somehow trying their level bus to to counter-attack the terrorists the problem is that they are still under the section of the web women industry so they cannot purchase weapon from up outside because government is they don't have enough enough equipment is to fight al-shabab now let's talk about another country that is trying to Grapple with the situation at hand made because of organizations like that it's Mali so how Mali is affected by this problem the nature of Mali and and the terrorist organizations are quite different from the rest of African countries and Mali is is quite a large land in central
[00:08:34] parts of Africa with the Central Central Republic of African and Ivory Coast it was quite near to be Burkina faster all are nearby to each other they built a new form of a terrorism organization which they call an alliance and desert Alliance uh like they created African and Arab mixed African and Arab Army which they call it like they are fighting for Jihad absolutely their way of abducting the where they were of of attacking the government is also different from the other parts but are these offshoots of al-Qaeda or offshoots of daesh or these are the organizations inspired by the al-Qaeda in daesh in Africa now they are getting the Revival of the previous uh Al-Qaeda movement in Africa the al-Qaeda movement in Africa after the uh after the counter attackers or the a lot of sanctions they felt like quite losing in power in the ground so this new form of the Gathering new power or the revive in
[00:09:42] form of is called Dash otherwise they they are the teacher and their student all the way they are almost the same and also Kenya is one of the countries that are badly affected Kenya is affected Kenya somehow is the only East African State maintained the democracy when you see in East African States the only state maintained the Democracy since their independence and Kenya is the second home of the of the United Nation organizations U.N organizations so it's the Hub of the of the of the international or what we call the Western tourism in Africa it's right next to the hotbed of al-shabab Somalia so where where al-shabab sees opportunity to to attack to attack Kenya they are attacking moles as we have seen investigate in Nairobi they are attacking universities as we have seen garissa University they are attacking also those who are traveling through the land so sometimes they are even updating the for the the foreigners from there so that is how how Kenya felt helpless against al-shiba and they send their
[00:10:49] army into Somalia for the support of for the support of the federal government to to comprehensive targets right but foreign richer economy but they are even available or present in countries as bad as Ethiopia I mean the country that is so badly entangled in all these food crises and Civil War you know parties fighting with the state state fighting with parties using airplanes drones and whatnot and and you find these organizations working in Ethiopia as well Ethiopia Ethiopia is the new new Administration came Ethiopia is is the uh is the second largest populated in in in Africa after Nigeria they they are also they were also the second largest growing economy in Africa just after Nigeria so you can understand that they were growing very fast enough population it has halted and now after when they see that the new Administration is crossing the the status quo Administration is the
[00:11:55] previous administration's Legacy they start creating a section War like the tribal war or the Nationalist war and that gives access to the also those the terrorist organizations that they can infiltrate and take the opportunity of the conflict similar problem prevails in Uganda as well Uganda Uganda is because of the dictatorship people are tired about the dictatorship and those who are against the tribalists who are against the government either they are getting support from the al-Qaeda organization linked related or they are getting from the militants who want to overtake the government so all is is related to the government organizations are not properly addressing the problem of their own Nation so less uh Kenya and Ethiopia more so in most of the cases they're fighting with the state and the state is not prepared for it in case of Ethiopia we have found out that the government is very heavily equipped and also in Kenya the government has a lot of resources to fight them out is that right yeah that's right now let's talk about in Syria
[00:13:03] another African country that is stuck in this conflict uh cycle for quite long now Algeria is one of the what I can say that it's called Islamic Jihad organization and they are linked to the Central Asian Islamic jihadisti they are the one of the oldest Islamic movement they are against the the former ruler of Abdullah who used to rule in Algeria for a long time their main reason is that they don't get even access to like normal practice of Islam because because the dictator was trying to embrace the Western culture into Algeria and the Algerian people were already feeling that they have been undermined by their faith their principle of Islam so they were having like a lot of Welcome inside inside the country then they they reform their form of of fight through education even through election but unfortunately when they didn't get any civilian response they go and take War
[00:14:10] and that is one of the most dangerous African terrorist organizations that you have ever come across so it's it is coming out of an indigenous German desire of people for their liking of religion that has been capitalized by terrorist organizations obviously yes and we are also seeing the similar pattern started to sprawl inside a country as mighty as Egypt one of the strongest partners of the West and one of the richest countries in Africa if I'm not mistaken yeah and they are most like economically they are mostly stabilized country in Africa after South Africa they they the Egypt the Egypt form of materialism is like uh they get influence from Hamas which is right across the across the border of the of Palestine when they see the the israelian occupation of Palestine the Palestinian helplessness they started campaigning inside thus Egypt and Egyptian people they respond very quickly and that was
[00:15:18] 1977 started it started from the 70s war and after that they grow slowly inside the country they started volunteer attack or to Israel by themselves and later which has gained momentum ever since Muhammad Morsi has been eliminated from the scene definitely and after that they they they get a lot of respect inside the Middle East and even even Saudi Arabia used to support in in early stage of this one last country that I would want to discuss from Africa Sudan so another strong African country that is grappling with the crisis definitely I'm talking about North Sudan Sudan Sudan is divided into three three categories one is the southern part of Sudan which gets this Independence on the other side of Sudan they are tribal tribal society and tribal Society the Arab Arab Africans and non-arab Africans in Sudan those who are tribals in in in in tafur they are fighting in the name of nationalism they said
[00:16:23] recognize our existence in the country but with the help of Islamic Jihad is the movement and that is how he present former former president Omar Hasan al-Bashir in Sudan he presented to the rest of the world that these people are not demanding legitimate demand of their nationalist interests they are spreading in terrorism even though as we know Osama Bin Laden was was based on on Sudan he invested a lot of projectists in Sudan before he shifted to Afghanistan but he never get influence in Sudan because Sudani people in the central part of Sudan they are most educated African society in in Africa almost 90 percent of the people are educated you can find like that you cannot manipulate by by religious ideology simply but when you go to the uh therefore area that is where they they get influence in because of the local conflict it's the interest of the people asking they State their legitimate demand and the states calling
[00:17:29] them terrorists all in all we see a sprawling effect of militancy growing in Africa and all of these countries are a factor thank you very much amanziki for being guest in today's program thank you for having me ladies and gentlemen was talking about the list of the American countries you made us swiftly go through the list of the African countries that are facing the problem of Isis and daesh let's not forget that this crisis took birth from the land called Iraq and Syria I mean this is the region where um Isis has originally taken birth back in 2014 ah they declared a state for some time so for some practical time the state uh support of the state of Iraq went into control of Isis and then many International Powers got involved into it and Isis eventually disintegrated from it you know when every time we talk about any issue related to Iraq uh my favorite guest is Nasir mohid who is originally is from Iraq and has a lot of insight of the subject let's ask from Nasir what is his Insight of the subject
[00:18:35] Nazir welcome to the show Once Again welcome Brothers fun tell us once again from the start I mean how does dayish or Isis started from Iraq because one of the theories that I have read uh in many Western media Outlets is that it was originally consisting of many people who skipped away from Saddam Hussein's Army well Isis started on the heritage of al-Qaeda in Iraq uh who fought against the Americans since 2003 and then they built the what so-called the ambar Islamic State and after that collapsed uh uh after the Americans operations and labar and all this region uh then uh after the in 2014 they started again and they announced the Islamic State in muscle by Nasir let me bring my original question back up and thank you very much for giving this background and but originally I wanted to understand if is it correct that most of the recruits in the Isis were the people running away from Saddam Hussein's Army who were angry about iraqi's Army being disintegrated and wanted to get back to action is that right well some observers see that Isis is actually leadership is from two levels
[00:20:18] one level is the highest governing uh uh members of Isis and they are mostly they are experts they are ex Iraqi Army leaders and they are they have experience in the military and in governing as well the other level which is the field management or the operational authorities and they have no uh previous connections of no previous experiences uh in Iraq or Syria they are normal people uh just uh ranked in in their positions that the leadership certainly came from the former soldiers of Iraqi Army but the recruits or the fighters on ground were actually coming from all over the world inspired by the idea of caliphate's establishment yes it's it's like that and that leadership as I told you uh one leadership uh have had uh very deep roots in the Iraqi military and in the Iraqi regime a previous regime and also in the same in Syria as well and uh the the at the second level they are mostly religious people religious leaders and normal people who uh who bought good ranks in their uh in the hierarchy of the organization so let's let's move
[00:22:06] forward for Iraq I think if we look into last 20 years of Iraq's uh fall down or Iraq's destruction I believe there are majorly two phases of it one is that wrath that Iraq had to Face by naturalized led by United States our started on Ron wrong round for which Plato many clarifications also came up which caused a lot of damage for Iraq's infrastructure and the second rat was coming from Isis that has done a lot of assassinations has destroyed this infrastructure of many cities if you compare the damages done by United States analyze done by ISIS to the beautiful country called Iraq which party has brought more miseries to the people of Iraq well no doubt the big powers are big Powers so uh no no nothing compared to the destruction Americans Americans brought but on the other hand Isis Isis
[00:23:12] Justified all the destruction all the killing happened all the fights between the uh and sunnis the fights between the different militias and tribes in Iraq that brought also a lot of Destruction in Iraq and many cities were were hundred percent collapsed like the city of mosul the city of falluja they were they were distracted the 100 percent like hundred percent of the buildings the houses were on ground the people uh over just a refugee and if you took Refuge to other cities or other countries as well so that brought a lot of victims a lot of Destruction would you give due credit to the leadership of Isis That by The Virtue of using the attractive idea of installing caliphate they started attracting people young people young Muslim people from many countries and that includes like I said at the beginning from countries like Canada and States Germany England people were coming from all of these places so is it because purely of the fact that the idea of caliphate was very attractive and was nicely propagated and propelled by the leadership of the aish well as I mentioned before that the the upper level of the leadership of Isis
[00:24:55] were experts and they had already connections and networks all around the world with not only people but with the governments with the intelligence agencies and with the militaries so there was a big game happening in behind and yes a lot of people joined some of them joined with the agendas some people joined just for some Islamic emotions but that brought a lot of Destruction to the country and to the region the same with ah later this problem also had its spillover effect to many of the Middle Eastern countries we know that there are countries that got affected because of the problem that originally started from Iraq and Syria how far you do you agree with that to many other countries in Egypt in the Cena region of Egypt in Libya in Middle
[00:26:08] Africa major Nigeria North Nigeria and Yemen in some East Asian countries and many countries in the world and in your opinion what caused the wrap up of Isis from Iraq and Syria there are many theories to it there are many uh people who believe that some International Powers actually made sure that Isis gets disintegrated but you being a local from Iraq tell us what is in your opinion the major reason of disintegration of Isis which at some point was looking to be the most formidable powerful force that existed in this entire region is still alive it's very weak now after the killing of the first leader the second and third leaders they were not as popular as their first leader so the the organization became quite
[00:27:18] weak in Iraq and Syria there were a lot of operations against it from the especially from the Americans so they were like eliminated and they got they are now in some area in between on the promoters of Iraq and Syria around 40 to 60 kilometers long they are there for reasons uh so they can they might be used in future uh so uh the organization uh became so weak they have around only 500 members now uh we remember when they entered mosul they reached to 20 000 members but now they they became only 500 members but even 500 members are still there and they are kept alive they are kept active for many reasons I was expecting you to give you credit to Iran and Hezbollah who have fought ferociously particularly due to defense and parts of Iraq that were of religious significance for both these sides but you have given credit to many other parties but the two that I just listed uh well uh they fought against Isis no doubt the uh Iranians and Hezbollah and also the militias in Iraq the army of Iraq they
[00:29:04] all fought against Isis but the whole game is not clear till now that many of servers they see that the political game and the influence of Isis was not only to the region where they were in control but also they had the links with the neighboring countries as well and they were they had a lot of mutual interest as well we don't forget that Isis used to sell the oil to the neighboring countries so how how can that they are fighting against Isis and at the same time they are cooperating with them to sell the oil thank you very much for being us in our program and ladies and gentlemen as you heard uh in the end there were two important points that he highlighted one is the integration of oil business into
[00:30:11] uh the problem of terrorism that actually creates a black economy that actually attracts a lot of criticism for everywhere else and the other thing is that from Iraq and Syria where they originally existed in such a strong strength now Isis or daesh that at some point had a registered Manpower of thirty thousand Fighters fighting in just one city of Mossel are now not more than 500 people not that they have all been beaten not that all have been killed not that all have run away but they have splintered in many of their subgroups and as amanzaki said in the first part of program that the problem has now gone toward many parts of Africa that serve as warm breeding ground nurseries for militant organizations like and Isis ladies and gentlemen since we in the south Asia are also one of the worst factors of the problem of terrorism I have now invited another guest in the show uh Syed Khalid
[00:31:16] Muhammad who is director general of a think tank called CommandEleven. join joining me on video link from SWAT and he's going to tell us about the regional implications of the phenomena of a daesh in their region welcome to the show and my first question is the how is is took birth in Afghanistan because Afghanistan is geographically far away from the region that they were originally operating from certainly Iran serves as a barrier between Iraq and Syria and Afghanistan and all of a sudden we started seeing the shootout of Isis and Afghanistan how did that happen can you briefly tell us about it when you talk about the birth of the Islamic State in Afghanistan um you need to understand that even though the Islamic State in uh Syria and Iraq announced in 2015 that they were expanding into Afghanistan we didn't actually see any signs of advancement uh it was 2016 July when iskb is Islamic State Quran Province the
[00:32:25] flavor of the region uh that they finally launched their first attack and and attacked a peaceful protest of Shia hazarus um 80 were killed 230 were injured and that was the first step that we saw Isis introduce itself at the time of the attack Isis iskb had already secured footing in the four districts of province in eastern Afghanistan along the Pakistan Afghanistan border but we have to understand it while most of the ice the Islamic State leadership in Afghanistan that came out in nangarhar Province were Pakistani militants who had long been settled in Afghanistan in the Springer Mountain areas bordering the Pakistani fata region while many people think that the Islamic States moved into Afghanistan because of the fight against the Americans I think we need to be more intelligent in understanding why the Islamic State moved into Afghanistan uh first off of course there's a direct conflict of the
[00:33:28] U.S military inside of Afghanistan secondly there's there is the potential to become a counter Force to the Taliban in Afghanistan uh many people at the time when Isis announced their their step into Afghanistan many people believed that the Taliban would not allow them to expand would not be would not allow them to operate um that was the case the Taliban was very quick in passing these people beating them over their heads but you need to remember that those two things are very clear third it also gives any foreign power I'm not just going to say The Afghani government any foreign power the ability to attack Pakistan directly to orchestrate the ongoing Insurgency that was going on in Afghanistan and to take out a price on Advanced on Pakistan if the Americans are any of the state decide that Pakistan should be punished brother Khalid thank you very much for giving all this background but uh I think we somehow have missed the presence of TTP which is also a major
[00:34:33] phenomena in this uh region now how does TTP gets factored into this conversation is it a rival organization or do they have similarity of interest in our region well here's here's the funny part um many people would like to say that uh TTP and Dish these two seem very similar they seem very different the problem we have here is that most of the ice the iskp data shift is in Afghanistan came from the TTP so people that were upset with the TTP leadership whether it be better soon or in the end fazula um they found a safe haven with the iskp understanding that most of these these militant camps these Terrace camps were all based in three provinces along the Pakistan Afghanistan border uh inside of Afghanistan it was very easy to draw people from there if you recall uh I think it was 2017 that uh Amazon was caught in Afghanistan by U.S forces uh the Afghanistan
[00:35:43] national directorate of of security was extremely upset with the US military because they had captured Amazon sheets uh uh the reason they were angry is because the amateur sheet was one of their assets and that's when this ball opened up as to what How Deep The power was against Pakistan um we also know that the Avan government prior to the TTP coming into its form uh was heavily supporting Mongol Palace Islam uh they were they also provide the TTP free movement Safe Haven and treatment in government hospitals so when the the advance the Iran government says that our soil will not be used for terrorist purposes or against any other country it's very difficult on the Pakistan side not to chuckle because we've seen what the the iranis do we've seen how honorable they are with their province with their promises and we don't expect anything different from them coming back to the problem of Afghan Taliban it's quite complicating to understand that while both of these parties I mean Taliban at some point in time were
[00:36:49] fighting against the foreign Invader called United States of America why do now they scuffle with each other what is the point in picking up weapons against each other and trying to cut each other out while both are militant organization as if as you have said some of their people have been moving around I've been joining one organization after another as we joined One Bank after shall we get another bank so what is the point in for these two to fight with each other yes yes I agree I agree uh there are numerous differences between the Avant Taliban and Islamic State coruscan province um first off you have to understand the vision that leads both is very different is the Islamic State leadership believes that they lead all Muslims when there's any conflict in in the in the region whereas the Taliban believes they are the only legitimate opposition to the Western dominance in Afghanistan when you look at those two pieces it's very difficult to understand how these two could cooperate together understanding ideologically ideological beliefs are
[00:37:57] different uh religious beliefs are different it makes it very difficult for for us to think that the Taliban and iskp could ever become allies uh the Taliban has also on numerous occasions warned iskp that they are formatting extremism and they're splitting up the ranks of the mujahideen which is also very true um we also have to keep in mind that Al-Qaeda has on numerous occasions renewed its oath of allegiance to the Taliban for the Islamic State to spread across Afghanistan they really need the Taliban to fall apart and in the current model it seems extremely unlikely that Taliban become weakened and I Islamic State correson Province will have a chance to spread across Afghanistan or to gain any kind of power in Afghanistan so if all of this is the scenario that you have just highlighted it's again very confusing to understand that if Pakistan has become any party to this conflict going on between Afghan Taliban and daesh because Pakistan has got no business to do with daesh
[00:39:05] Pakistan does not even as you have matched you're not even fall in the agenda list that you have underlined so far so how serious of a problem would Dash be for a country like Pakistan when we talk about the risk to Pakistan um we have to understand that Pakistan is always at risk there are many International intelligence agencies there are many uh foreign groups that are interested in destabilizing Pakistan that game's stabilization is due to wanting to make sure that Pakistan is weak into such a point that they can take our nuclear assets I think it was 2017 when there was an article written during the during the zadavi government that the best answer to Pakistan and their debt is to buy buy their nuclear assets and wipe out their debt so the Americans have always been working for looking for a way to buy our nuclear weapons weak in Pakistan and put us in a position where we will not be able to defend ourselves against multiple threats now we understand the Indians are also involved in this because they were given a very very large swaths of lead to work with inside of Afghanistan whether it be from an economic point of
[00:40:11] view whether it be from a supporting point of view for the Americans even though General Machado while he was president when the when the the Twin Towers were attacked one of the conditions that the general Machado put down on the Americans in Pakistan cooperating was that India would not be given space inside of Afghanistan to operate uh the Americans opened the door to the Indian Indian government said come and do whatever you want so there there was a little problem there um the risk to Pakistan will only be understood if the TTP starts attacking inside of Pakistan again as they announced last week that they've given up the ceasefire and they will now start Waging War against Pakistan thank you very much for being yes in our program ladies and gentlemen this was our detailed segment about the risks of daesh in this part of world we'll take a break and we'll join you back with the second segment of program stay with us thank you
[00:41:36] thank you welcome back ladies and gentlemen as Russia and Ukraine's war is not over there are serious developments that are taking place every week and therefore program fault lines by the which of its design cannot ignore the developments taking place now this development that we are about to discuss as far more serious than all the developments that have taken place in the past and the development is that you grind for the first time has attacked Russia 600 miles inside Russian territory yes the attack was made evidently through some or apparently through some drone that Ukraine has developed overnight and has hit with Precision inside Russia's Mainland on an air base this is a big leap because now the war has gone
[00:42:41] inside Russia and the implications both for the politics and for the military of Russia are for reaching with regards to this attack also the fact that there are some gaps that have started to appear within the ranks of the European nations uh president of France has given a statement while giving interview to The Economist magazine wherein he said what we are currently experiencing is a brain death of NATO this is one serious statement to talk about this I have invited a guest from Washington DC his name is Gabriel narona he is former advisor to State Department of United States Gabriel welcome to the show absolutely thank you for having me Ali what are your remarks with regards to the attack that has taken place deep inside Russia how concerning it is for you so the Ukrainian forces have developed long-range drones with uh the ability to
[00:43:47] strike deeper than Russian territory um and over the last couple days they've been striking Air Force bases um destroying Russian bombers which have been used to attack Ukrainian facilities and military installations um these attacks I think surprised Russia the fact that they were able to go in so deep um I don't think it's a bad thing though look Russia uh started this Invasion started this war um Ukraine has absolutely every single right to strike within Russian territory um and it's going to send the message to Russia that as long as it continues this war it's going to have to pay the price they've already lost about half of their military equipment they have about a hundred thousand casualties and the question for Vladimir Putin and for the Russian people is how long are they willing to keep up this war um when it's become quite clear they're not going to win they're not going to take over Kiev and their losses are going to be astronomical they're going to continue to rise and so I think the United States and NATO should do everything we can to continue to equip you can find in defending itself that sends a strong message to every country
[00:44:53] around the world who's thinking of invading other countries that it's really not worth it Gabriel I found you very straightforward and very open-minded while responding to this question I wish United States uh diplomacy or United States state department would have adopted a similar approach U.S just like many of the developments in the past is quite reluctant to take explicit responsibility of this attack I'm not saying that United States has done it or not done it but what do you believe can be the reason of having a bit of reluctance in taking their responsibility well the United States has actually been very reluctant to provide Ukraine with any weapons that have the ability to strike within Uh Russian territory um for a while they didn't provide the high Mars weapons because they had long range so they only provided the short short range version of those now there's a new weapon called the attackems and they've actually programmed those weapons so that they are unable to fire into Russian territory so I actually think there's there's a lot of reluctance from the United States from NATO into attacking Russian territory
[00:45:58] because most leaders are concerned that it could sort of give incentives and and provoke Russia into doing even more drastic attacks um personally I think that that fear is a little bit misguided but I think it's strong enough that makes me question that the idea that the United States and Nitto would help with these drone developments um ultimately at the end of the day if a country like Iran can develop these long-range drones I don't think it's who and Iran is that terribly an advanced country I don't think it's out of the question for uh Ukraine which has a long history of military and technological development to build these drones on their own but there are many problems associated with it I mean Ukraine is in a state of four it is being shoveled with rockets with bombs the military of Russia is moving in and out it doesn't have that amount of peace that it is generally that is generally required to develop a weapon to do research and development to test it and then to you know send it inside how can you pull that through made of an
[00:47:07] all-out war on your country I mean they they probably led the efforts did they have some uh technical assistance from people in the west you know it's it's certainly likely um it's certainly possible that that components of those drones came from U.S or NATO countries um but I would be a little surprised if if the Weaponry itself if the Drone itself was produced and and sold to Ukraine by by Western countries it just doesn't fit with the other pattern of weapon sales uh to Ukraine thus far but will natto be happy of the developments that have taken place I mean the new development that war has actually went inside the mainland Russia well now to be happy with it I look I think it's uh NATO is always a little um wary whenever conflict gets uh gets out of control um but I don't think that these attacks are going to spark a Russian attack against NATO installations again the Russian forces are are decimated now they don't want to start anything with with a direct conflict of NATO perhaps it means what will what will likely
[00:48:19] happen is that Russia will carry out sort of a a direct attack against Kiev or maybe even um out west in leviv which is quite close to the Polish border in sort of a in retaliation for these attacks um but I don't think there's a massive risk to Nato itself from these attacks um I think also Russia's ammunitions are running quite low they don't even have the ability to um do certain types of attacks out into Western Ukraine at this moment and my last question would it not be very embarrassing for uh President Putin because he's now pushed to a corner not only that his strategy in Ukraine are not working but for him the war that he started outward has started being you know hitting the Targets in Saras country is it not pushing Putin to a corner yeah I think look if you look at Russian nuclear Doctrine um they limit the use of web of of
[00:49:23] nuclear weapons to instances where they say the territorial Integrity of Russia is being threatened um I don't think that strikes against against Russian territory would trigger that it's more a land Invasion um what concerns me is when when they say that Crimea is part of Ukraine that luhansken done yet eastern Ukraine are part of Russia the implication is that if Ukrainian forces physically crossed into those territories that the Russians would use that as an excuse and as a pretext to use uh weapons of mass destruction I don't think that if a if an aircraft is blown up in near Moscow or a pipeline is blown up that that triggers the same nuclear uh conditions in the Russian military system and in Putin's mind um ultimately I think there's been my concern is over the last year there's been so many instances where people in the west and the rest of the world say what might do how can we make sure Putin doesn't escalate that's the wrong that's the wrong approach Putin has escalated every single day of this war from the moment his troops crossed into Ukrainian
[00:50:27] territory they have been escalating um we can't play that game forever we can't always worry about what Putin will do sometimes we just have to defend or defend Ukraine against the war that that Russia started thank you very much Gabriel Lerona for being us in our program today ladies and gentlemen the war between Russia and Ukraine is far from over and with each development taking place against Russia the stakes are getting higher for the entire world we need to keep an eye on the developments and all the nations need to play their part to try to bridge the gap that is taking place between the two sides we'll join you next week with another program and until then I love us