Fault Lines · Aired April 20, 2021

Summary

PTV World's Fault Lines on President Biden's decision to end the US war in Afghanistan, the Taliban's position and what the withdrawal means for Pakistan.

Transcript

This transcript was generated from the broadcast and lightly edited. Sponsor messages and music are removed, speaker names are corrected, and some remarks by panelists and guests that do not reflect the views of CommandEleven Intelligence have been removed. Automatic transcription may contain errors; the video is the record.

[00:00:00] this is PTV World i am sayyid shabbat ali and you're watching Fault Lines president biden declared on wednesday that it is time to end the four ever war in afghanistan saying that the united states had long ago accomplished its main mission and that leaving american forces there was no longer worth the cost in blood and money speaking from the same spot in white house where president george w bush ordered the start of war after september 11 attacks nearly two decades ago mr biden made a case that there was no longer any justification if there was any to believe that united states military presence could turn afghanistan into a stable democracy but there are concerns in afghanistan taliban now precisely know when the afghan government will lose the military support of their principal supporters the chaos and uncertainty is frightening the afghanis if the country is inching toward a civil war are taliban again becoming the rulers of the land watch the package before we bring our first guest to the program with the recent developments in afghan

[00:01:40] peace process president joe biden has announced the withdrawal of all the american troops from afghanistan over the coming months completing military exit by the 20th anniversary of september 11th attacks that drew united states into its longest war ever nato allies have also decided to start withdrawing forces from the resolute support mission in afghanistan by may the first with plans to complete the drawdown of all the truth within a few months we will start the withdrawal of nato risk to support mission forces by may 1st nato secretary general jen stoltenberg called the move a start of a new chapter in nato's relationship with afghanistan saying that allies and partners will continue to stand with the afghan people but it is now for the afghan people to build a sustainable peace the united nations however said it will maintain its political and humanitarian mission to afghanistan despite the departure of united states and nato troops later this year stefan dejarik the spokesperson to the united nations secretary general said it was clear and obvious that the troops departure will have an impact on

[00:02:45] the country as a whole the united nations assistance mission in afghanistan is a small political operation comprised of approximately 1 200 employees excluding the peacekeepers the vast majority of whom are afghan nationals with all the united nations agencies included the organization's total presence in afghanistan amounts to approximately 4 000 people roughly 75 percent are gone pakistan in particular has had a very valuable role in brokering peace between taliban and the united states on multiple occasions pakistan has reiterated that there is no military solution in afghanistan and says it will continue to work together with the international community in efforts for lasting peace and stability this assistance by pakistan led to the u.s taliban agreement of february 29th 2020 which laid the foundation for a comprehensive intra-afghan peace agreement including a permanent ceasefire to bring an end to the violence in afghanistan the question now remains how will the afghan peace process and the intra-afghan dialogue shape to join me in my program my first guest

[00:03:56] is a professor from university of maryland professor david hagerty professor welcome to the program my first question from you has the war in afghanistan come to an end for united states or has u.s actually accomplished some objectives in afghanistan greetings it's a great pleasure for me to be on fault lines and i thank you for the opportunity to speak to you syed shabbat ali and your other guests on the program about the situation in afghanistan in particular as it relates to the biden administration's decision uh to remove american forces within uh roughly the next four to five months the first question uh was has the war in afghanistan come to an end and i think the answer to that question is uh the war itself probably not um it depends on the afghan leadership and the anti-regime forces and whether or not they can make some kind of a deal

[00:05:02] a political deal to move forward uh in concert the u.s role yes is coming to an end in terms of military forces soldiers on the ground in afghanistan we have to be clear about that president biden is adamant that 20 years has been too long you probably recall that in 2009 when uh the obama administration was considering its policy on afghanistan uh biden was the vice president and he was on the side of arguing for no surge in forces and a move to a more offshore counter-terrorism posture with respect to afghanistan he lost in that debate he was outvoted and obama surged 50 000 troops into afghanistan um with the uh sort of strategic goal of uh putting enough uh into the fight against the taliban that they would see

[00:06:08] the virtue of a ceasefire and a uh a sincere diplomatic negotiation to end the conflict so the u.s role in actual fighting on the ground in afghanistan is over that's for sure and basically the biden administration's view is that it's time for the international community uh including the united states and including pakistan to really step up and help to make sure that all the progress that's been made since 2001 2002 uh is not wasted and there has been a lot of progress as i hope to talk about today professor hegerty professor hegeti i'll have to stop you here for a while tell me is this the end of american interest in afghanistan or is it just a shift in its strategy and u.s is just trying to eliminate the boots on ground so the question is has the u.s achieved its goal in afghanistan or has it realized that it has goals that are unachievable what's behind the thinking of this decision that happened this week and uh it's a complex question has every

[00:07:16] question involving war and peace is there are multiple goals and i would argue that many of them in this case have been met in afghanistan since 2001 some of them have not been met but let me just go through some of the things that we need to i think be cognizant of when we're talking about you know the success or failure of this overall effort first of all the taliban government which was hosting al-qaeda was basically uh decimated made to flee and put out of business for a short period of time secondly al-qaeda forces themselves were disrupted and fragmented and al qaeda core no longer exists in afghanistan because of u.s and nato and other forces the political situation is completely different a constitutional democracy has been built in afghanistan there have been regular elections it's not a perfect system but it's a good system and for the first time

[00:08:23] it is a democratic system uh warts and all uh the u.s has also conducted a massive relief and reconstruction effort in afghanistan to the tune of 145 billion dollars uh the united states has nurtured and tried to enable the emergence of an afghan civil society that represents every conceivable interest and is very very vigorous today uh with many uh women leading different efforts uh in a very impressive way that we didn't see before um combat operations came to 825 billion dollars so if we add that to the 145 uh probably this year uh the overall number is going to cross the 1 trillion dollar mark which is a huge amount of money 50 billion dollars per year uh the goal that has not been achieved unfortunately is the goal of leaving afghanistan with a prosperous

[00:09:31] democratic stable secure government and society unfortunately that goal has not been fully realized although a lot of the steps toward that goal have been achieved but the president has determined that at a cost that the american people are willing to pay that goal is out of reach without a huge infusion of resources military and diplomatic and economic and as he put it a couple days ago we tried that that was what we did but we decided in 2009 that we were going to surge and really pump up the effort uh and frankly it just didn't work here we are a decade later so that's professor hagerty in the past when the united states was not there was not there in afghanistan there was taliban were ruling the countries united states came and tried to install a government in place which is even today in place but again as united states is about to leave afghanistan taliban are occupying the major holding of land

[00:10:38] taliban are still the strongest side on the table and there is a likelihood that afghanistan might just go back to civil war how does that sound to the american polity so on the matter of is this the end of u.s interest in afghanistan and attention to afghanistan or is it just a withdrawal of american boots on the ground the answer is distinctly the latter the united states will remain very engaged with afghanistan and with this part of the world in general uh frankly as it stands now there are only two missions that us military forces are a part of in afghanistan right now there's been a huge drawdown for years those two missions are the counter-terrorism mission uh as well as the training of the afghan security forces so those are the only two things that are going on right now the us has not been uh engaging in ground fighting with the anti-regime forces at all it has been providing air

[00:11:45] support uh in engagements against the taliban but that's it nothing on the ground the main mission going forward will continue to be the counter-terrorism mission and the administration has looked at that and they've decided that while that might be somewhat diminished it will still be possible to have over the horizon counter terrorism capabilities things like aerial reconnaissance and rapid deployment forces from nearby areas there's a whole range of things that the u.s air force can do in counter-terrorism activities so that's all being worked out and will continue to be worked out as the ground forces are removed the u.s will be still very very generous in terms of economic and humanitarian aid toward afghanistan because that is needed it's not uh debated at all that's the need military assistance including training that will be lessened

[00:12:53] but i'm not sure it'll go away i mean it's quite possible that uh private contractors could train up afghan forces uh almost as well as u.s military professor the problem is not only military in nature there is a huge economic front of the crisis as well the fran government that is at the moment in place is almost solely reliant on the donations and the financial patronage of u.s government we don't know whether this patronage is also fading off from ground or is it only the american troops that are leaving the country can you enlighten us a bit more about it so looking toward the future what would the u.s do if a civil war were to break out in afghanistan in the next few years i think that frankly it's impossible to say in the abstract it would depend a lot on who the combatants are if there was involvement of say isis or al qaeda or other terrorist groups significant involvement that would be a

[00:13:59] real problem in the eyes of the united states because that represents a potential uh comeback of a threat to american homeland security um we shouldn't mince words on this no u.s president is going to want to send forces back into this theater nobody's going to be enthusiastic about it so that's the kind of the default view i suspect that if the us did decide that there was a potential terrorist threat building up that offshore capabilities would be the first choice and that the u.s would try to carry out military operations but not with soldiers on the ground in afghanistan but i really i have a hard time seeing the american president doing that at least this american president i can't speak to what happens in the future but we have to remember you know there's been a lot of death and destruction in afghanistan uh among afghans more than anybody else the

[00:15:09] u.s has suffered losses 2500 lives roughly 20 000 uh casualties uh something like 760 000 americans have gone to fight in afghanistan and some of them multiple tours two or three tours in afghanistan um there's been a real toll uh on the united states from uh 20 years of combat so i think it's going to really be the last choice on the menu of options as to how to respond thank you very much professor hagerty for being my guest from maryland ladies and gentlemen we'll take a break here and we'll join back with the second segment of the program stay with us welcome back i have with me from geneva mr torik for hadi who is an ex-advisor to the president of afghanistan also uh the pointer of modern iran a currency and an expert of iran affairs uh tauric welcome to the program thank you uh do you think actually united states planned to leave afghanistan after 20 years of occupation but now in turmoil well hopefully that the pea stocks would bear fruit

[00:17:10] and we are all hoping while trying that some sort of stability comes to afghanistan and the world also wishes including pakistan and then yes for a few years afghanistan will need financial assistance from the world tariq if you were there in the place of the president of afghanistan what options do you think you would have had at the moment well to continue talks with various afghan factions um inside kabul because there is a high council of national reconciliation to have direct talks with the council not through emissaries and representatives and offer solutions basically peace talks have been stuck because not a very crisp offer has been given to taliban on power sharing and it is time that something new after eight months of

[00:18:21] talks in doha be presented to the taliban that they can't refuse so but the solution would be to bring the taliban into the power structure in afghanistan and from then on decide on other issues like elections and and governance type if we put election precondition the taliban have already rejected that and so it's a non-starter so first they have to be inside the power structure and then become a political force rather than a military force and uh hopefully we can have elections down the line but not now but this is not an option at the moment taliban are not uh you know very fond of our actions and not willing to become part of anything like that so in that case what have been your options yes taliban or not in favor of elections

[00:19:31] now maybe even philosophically they are not in favor of elections as we know it in western style elections but they might agree to some sort of system which would be a parallel to what you see in iran right now which is a number of people are selected first to run and a number of people can vote for them and those people are representatives of people so there are so many ways to basically select a leader but if the the method of selection is the cause for the conflict it is fair to say that we have to look at the method of selection tariq tell me if the uzbeks tajiks hazaras factions like dostum are capable to join hands with the government and stand against uh taliban to make sure that taliban do not take over the entire country once again do you think that physically probable well the african national army is composed of all the uh italies of afghanistan and the afghan national army right now is opposing the taliban and we hope that through peace talks there won't be a need for that that

[00:21:07] eventually the taliban can make peace and join their national army that's the plan that we're hoping for uh we don't want more fighting actually you might not want but taliban have been fond of fighting that is what they have been doing uh to defeat two superpowers one after another and right now when united states is on brinks of leaving the country their hubris is on a different level so uh so do you think uh i mean when taliban have all this firepower on their side talks and offers would suffice to avoid the war in afghanistan yes because taliban were fighting against the us which they deemed as the occupiers the us is leaving after that the taliban fight will not be so popular with the population of afghanistan so the people of afghanistan will ask them what are you fighting for now and that is a legitimate question at that point 2021

[00:22:18] foreign forces are out that was the biggest issue that were putting on the table for fighting but once the foreign forces are out yes the government will open the door for them and they can come and participate even a generous participation but if they continue to fight i think the populations of afghanistan and different areas would ask that legitimate question and if the and that is where uh the popularity of the taliban if there is any will go down because there's no reason for fighting the us is out now who are you fighting against the afghans so that is the point that might change in the battlefield in the psychology of the battlefield and the people of afghanistan will defend themselves if they feel that the taliban are here to impose a way of life and indeed the taliban or defending an economist brand of islam that is not only a danger for

[00:23:24] afghanistan but it's also a danger for pakistan remember we have a border but the problems are the same across the border i totally agree with you on that tell me um there are many international commentators that are now saying that taliban might not this time try to take the central government of afghanistan and then to deal with the rest of the world as a government that is supposed to have relation with other nation states they might this time think of holding a larger territory of land operating it independently and allow you know someone else to to lead the government in kabul which might be a very weak and symbolic structure dealing or coordinating different affairs with the you know league of the nations how do you comment on that would you agree to it with your understanding of iran matters well if the fighting stops in afghanistan and violence against civilians stop this is a solution but we would like the taliban to have interest

[00:24:29] in what's going on in the central government and have rules and responsibilities the taliban or afghans and if there are areas that come under their control in southern afghanistan and southwestern afghanistan in points of eastern afghanistan if they don't want to deal with the central government that would be a partition of afghanistan which we don't wish nobody wishes that the taliban should move into a political structure they should have representatives in the government the if they are holding territory they should be part of the policy making in afghanistan they should see the difficulties of ruling a country that has challenges poverty climate and they should be part of the the the whole uh comprehensive way of running the country and agree with other afghans

[00:25:37] we might see things very differently but the taliban have said that they recognize that afghanistan is a diverse country and then they have to demonstrate that and sit down with others around the table to manage this diverse country thank you very much torik for being on my show again it's always a pleasure to have you here ladies and gentlemen i am now joined by an defense analyst based in islamabad his name is khalid mahmood is joining my show for the first time welcome to the program thank you very much for having me on the show i'm looking forward to having a good conversation with you khalid tell me about this taliban issue it is being often said in the international media particularly the print media is very vocal about it that taliban are not centrally integrated into a unison there are many factions that have conflict of interest or at least a difference of opinion with each other the stalwarts of their leadership are all gone now and these are the times when taliban can

[00:26:43] easily disintegrate how would you comment on that i think we i think you've got that point very clear um if you remember when the door deal was signed between the taliban and the trump administration uh at that point we had many factions of the taliban expressing their disapproval with ap steel at any time understanding that they would have to give up the islamic values that they they believe in that they previously governed with to fit into a american-style democracy many factions were against this idea i think a lot of the factions have now become very uh pleased with the fact that the us has pulled the full back from the agreement they had made this is one of the beliefs that the the factional factional leaders the sudo leaders inside the taliban had that the u.s had many times made promises that they would would reduce troops that they would help to decrease the violence find a way to integrate the taliban into the government but all those problems were left empty all hollow promises many people within the taliban leadership believe that this

[00:27:46] also was a hollow promise so a lot of the factions when deed was made they said that we aren't going to go along with this we will not believe this and a lot of pressure was put on the main leadership of the taliban to find a way to back this thing off because this was not going to happen the way they watch it what we have now is a lot of the factions are now expressing greater support for the taliban many people are saying that there will be a great deal of bloodshed now but we need to be concerned more about disruptors then we need to be concerned about the factions that's alibaba groups like islamic state the ttp in afghanistan these groups can cause a lot of problems for any kind of peace deal that may happen in afghanistan need to be very clear that they are the government they need to be concerned now holland it's a very tricky situation for united states at the moment the commitment that u.s government had made two years ago to go from afghanistan completely by first of may has not been met and yet the president of united states has given another deadline that looks fairly close

[00:28:52] and that apparently looks a final call but taliban say that the agreement or the promises made to them have not been met do you think now on you know the missing of this deadline or first of may taliban may start a season of offenses or a fresh fight against uh united states which now has a very symbolic or little presence on ground i don't think we need to doubt that at all i mean uh the taliban statement after biden announced that uh he was going to extend what he was considering extending the withdrawal deadline the taliban made it very clear this day if the us stayed one day after may 1st there would be a spring offensive the taliban would kick up violence again the problem we're looking at right now is it's not just complete taliban violence can be concerned about the iran national forces will be attacking taliban outposts uh the taliban will be carrying out assassination targeted assassinations against government officials they will be after senior leadership in the us military they will take out they

[00:29:57] will carry out attacks against the us military but we need to be more concerned right now about whether the taliban actually has the ability to bring peace in afghanistan i mean yes according to many of the international reports there's 12.5 percent of rajasthan's controlled by a taliban our estimations put it somewhere around 65 70 when they have 70 control the country they really don't have to make a lot of concessions in terms of what can and cannot happen so we're very concerned with the taliban taking a very strict line now and saying that these will be the guidelines and we will carry out very very heavy attacks against the military against the iran military against kabul against government officials just to get our point across that we don't need to compromise anymore so yes we need to take that that is that into consideration that the taliban has been very has been using various militant factions or very various militant outfits uh placed in afghanistan against pakistan and pakistan has given all

[00:31:03] these evidences in form of a dozier to united nation it is said by some critics that now when afghanistan is gradually moving toward a post-america scenario india might not be very comfortable with taliban taking a major lead now because this might end all the strategic resources that they have developed to destabilize pakistan how would you comment on that completely agreed completely agreed uh india has spent 20 years investing into infrastructure investing into narratives investing into getting a mindset built in afghanistan that pakistan is against the iran people that is not true but india has done such a good job of placing that inside the event mentality that pakistan now has another world to fight inside of afghanistan that we are somehow their enemies india has been able to leverage every militant group they have inside of afghanistan whether it be the volatile liberation army or the ttp or the jungi or anyone else that may be aligned right now the problem we have to understand

[00:32:05] is that india is going to have a lot more problems with letting china and russia into afghanistan because china being inside of afghanistan being a strong and infrastructure partner being someone that can assure security on the ground that takes away the indian counterpart because india has so far been able to get their influence into afghanistan based on the amount of money they have spent and the amount of training they brought in with their military yes we understand their military training has been more towards the militants but the iran national army does still see the indian army as an asset to them if china comes in and they become a strong force inside of afghanistan which is what we see happening with china russia and and pakistan seeing such stabilizing force we will be minimalized and india will not accept that they've already made that clear there's a number of reports that come out of the indian same tanks talking about the most american world inside of algona what india needs to do to move inside of that world so we do know there will be a militant response there will be an economic

[00:33:09] response there will be probably a social response but we need to understand that india is not going to go heavy from the afghanistan side to make the western border much weaker for us much Khalid for being on my show ladies and gentlemen we'll take a break here and we'll join back with the third segment of the program stay with us welcome back in the last segment of my program i have with me dr shabana who is actually from kardashian university department of defense and strategic studies dr welcome to the program how do you think what is running in the mind of president biden at the moment who has not allowed his troops to withdraw on 1st of may but has given a very nearby deadline of september 2021. you know if you look back the track of the administration the u.s president president trump and now the president biden

[00:34:35] they have been swindling by giving the statements from four weeks to 10 weeks to a year so this is nothing new really what is happening in american mind obviously we cannot be experts that what are they thinking but what we can add is that if one can judge really is that they are trying they are fed up of being engaged in afghanistan and that is a very very short-sighted perception on the american end and they want an exit at the at the earliest as possible that was one of his agendas during the polls for presidency so this is happening here and uh unfortunately this is not going to end the turmoil that they have created in afghanistan since last 20 years doctrine do you think this is going to be an end of american interest in afghanistan because america has been there for the last 20 years realistically speaking i don't think so it's going to be an end americans cannot afford to end an engagement in this part of the world whether it is engaging with russia or

[00:35:39] with china or with pakistan or the larger interests there are multiple challenges that they are facing regarding their perception of bri cpac how to deal and develop india as a counterweight to the china and so they cannot afford they can neglect and they can be you know overlook the fact that how to put afghanistan in order with the original agenda where they came in 20 years earlier but unfortunately what it seems if you read the american mind is that biden president biden is thinking and working on three lines on your strategic elements number two is the climate and number three is the pandemic so these three and economic uplift of americans to compete with the rising china lok sabha we have missed the americans have missed the deadline of pay and they have given a deadline that's very close so taliban at the moment are not happy about this arrangement and they have given their official statement that america has not lived up to their expectations and now they are not under any burden of any agreement

[00:36:43] they have also decided not to participate in the process of negotiations to be done in turkey how do you think talabanas are going to respond to the situation at the moment actually it seems a double track for taliban to my perception because uh since if you read the record of the developments in afghanistan talibans have been successfully capturing the main lands of afghanistan and this gives them more boost to their insurgency or their movement many people even from uzbek elements and they have been co-opted with the talibans and they're making already a broad bait agenda and the arrangements unfortunately since the us and the other partners didn't materialize the deal that was originally struck by president trump with the talibans in office so what we see is basically is i think taliban cutting off from the american peace deal is basically they can afford they are in a much powerful if you look at the geostrategic dynamics they are in much powerful position in afghanistan and how the important point we should be

[00:37:48] registering how it is going to register abroad based afghanistan peace process in afghanistan this is the major dilemma that nobody is looking into it we have heard the united states president's speech which says they have achieved their objectives they have achieved their targets and uh they have said that there is no is on round or iss on ground do you agree with these objectives that have been accomplished or is it a bit of optics that is at play at the moment i think this is they want to go home with the face saving techniques the fact is that americans have not achieved their objective yes they have achieved the objective of being on ground on afghanistan and being in in sort of semi-arrangement and backing the regimes from one or another type they have not they came where if i remember they came with the promise of rebuilding afghanistan they came with the problem of economically uplifting afghanistan eliminating al-qaeda yes al-qaeda was was dislodged from afghanistan we must admit um osama bin laden was killed in an

[00:38:52] operation by americans but and many other leaders this was their militarily you know good or whatever positives that american think of but what about the losses that americans have suffered we must also think that american families and of those who were killed in this process they are also the casualties of the war on terror so if you look at the balance sheet the economic or the financial cost of u.s staying there is huge and so that is a pressure on biden and was a pressure on trump how to come back by minimizing the military and the financial cost of their stay in afghanistan shabbat from qatar talks doha talks to troika in in russia and then the turkey talks that taliban have refused to participate in how do you you see these negotiations and has anything been achieved out of it or not i think a lot has been achieved if i uh you know the why russia has engaged in afghanistan they have been quietly talking to taliban as well and they have also been obviously engaged with the nathans but

[00:39:58] more with the taliban and anti-northern or anti-american forces and china has been in contact and has you know yielded and also been receptive to their ideas and hosted them as well and in the three party arrangements or of course pakistan has been a key player there so what it seems is iran is also heavily engaged indirectly within consultation with even the taliban elements so what really it comes to mind is that everybody around afghanistan if you look at regional scenario they want to have a stability in afghanistan and there seems to be an underline that they are not satisfied with the ongoing americans presence there and lack of durable peace which the americans have failed to deliver on all broad meters in afghanistan so do you foresee a civil war coming in afghanistan once again and uprooting millions of fans from their places or do you think the sanity will prevail this time i think the first part that you said a sort of uncertainty

[00:41:02] will prevail in afghanistan for some time as i've said earlier the talibans are in much much strong position than they were earlier and there if you read the finest kabul texts and other you know newspaper sources that they the people of the civil society they are fed up of war a journal and they want to co-opt with the sort of taliban arrangement provided the taliban gives them assurances that their rights and and their liberties and will be protected and uh regarded so this is one thing yes there is going to be a very very negative fallout on people at large on economy at large and on other dimensions of social development but unfortunately if afghanistan slips to into the turmoil it's going to take a heavy toll on its neighbors finally specifically pakistan final question about how pakistan is setting into this equation and how pakistan will be affected with the future course of thing in afghanistan frankly i think if you read the history pakistan has been has been the most sufferer on turmoil in

[00:42:09] afghanistan although we have been labeled as the bad boys by most of the outside players even at times by the regional players but the fact is that pakistan has beard afan refugees very graciously still houses it even after al-qaeda's operation was dislodged even after that and even in the in the later stage that is coming we are forcing more you know uh people coming from afghanistan and on humanitarian gown obviously the pakistan has to host them and secondly the pakistan interest i think pakistan has always remain an unsung hero in the history of afghanistan if you talk to the civil society in afghanistan it is very very disheartening they have a lot of misperceptions wizard of pakistan role there and that is not because of their own making because of the negative propaganda that has been generated by the outside players or the spoilers who have been working very actively in afghanistan sophia thank you very much dr saba for being in my house ladies and gentlemen as we are going closer towards september 2021's deadline

[00:43:19] there is a lot that has to happen in afghanistan the the response of taliban from between may and between september is very important we just hope that afghanistan does not become a place full of crisis once again and it does not uh become a war zone once again uh for the civil war that has destroyed the peace and stability of the country for such a long time we'll join you with another program next week and until then allah office

All Fault Lines episodes